What are the New Lancaster, Indiana Zip Codes for 2020, 2019Primary Zip Codes for New LancasterZip CodePrimary CitySecondary City46036ElwoodNew Lancaster, Curtisville, Duck Creek, Leisure, Meadowood Est, Meadowood Estates, Pipe Creek, Rigdon, West ElwoodCities sharing Zip Codes with New LancasterZip CodePrimary CitySecondary CityMore Information46036ElwoodCurtisville46036ElwoodDuck Creek46036ElwoodLeisure46036ElwoodMeadowood Est46036ElwoodMeadowood Estates46036ElwoodNew Lancaster46036ElwoodPipe Creek46036ElwoodRigdon46036ElwoodWest ElwoodAdvertisements